Running out of shaving cream ranks somewhere between a minor inconvenience and a complete disaster, depending on your skin sensitivity and beard type. The question inevitably arises: can you shave without shaving cream, or are you destined for a day of razor burn and regret?
To separate fact from fiction, I've consulted two industry experts: Stefan Clark, senior barber at Murdock London, and Shady Harb, grooming specialist at Beauty Club London. Their insights offer practical solutions for those emergency situations when your bathroom cabinet has let you down, but your five o'clock shadow still needs taming.
Why Use Shaving Cream?
Shaving cream performs several essential functions: it softens the beard hair for easier cutting, provides lubrication for smoother razor glide, creates a protective barrier between the blade and your skin and helps keep track of where you've already shaved.
what to read next
'Traditional shaving creams and gels are specifically formulated to cushion the razor and protect your skin from irritation,' explains Harb. The Cremo Sensitive Shave Cream exemplifies these qualities and is a staple in my bathroom cabinet.
Hawkins & Brimble Traditional Shave Cream, Nourishing Mens Shaving Cream
Kiehl's Ultimate Brushless Shave Cream - Blue Eagle
Can You Shave Without Shaving Cream?
The short answer? Yes, but with caveats.
'Shaving without a proper cream or gel isn't ideal, but in a pinch, it can be done — if you approach it the right way,' advises Clark. 'The key is ensuring some kind of lubrication to reduce friction, prevent irritation and avoid unnecessary tugging on the hair.'
Harb concurs: 'It can be safe under certain conditions. However, if you're in a situation where you don't have access to these products, make sure your face is well hydrated.'
Risks and Side Effects of Shaving Without Shaving Cream
Going rogue with your razor and shaving without proper lubrication can lead to razor burn, nicks, cuts, and increased skin irritation due to excess friction between the blade and your skin. You're also more likely to experience ingrown hairs and premature dulling of your razor blades, making future shaves more uncomfortable.
- Razor burn: Painful, red irritation that develops after shaving.
- Nicks and cuts: These occur when the blade doesn't glide smoothly.
- Ingrown hairs: An improper shaving technique can force hairs to grow back into the skin.
- Dryness and flaking: Razors can strip the skin of natural oils, leading to dryness.
- Premature razor dulling: More resistance means your blades will wear out faster.
Shaving Cream or Gel Alternatives
When you're stuck without your usual products, a rummage through your bathroom cabinet or kitchen can yield some surprisingly effective substitutes.
Hair Conditioner
Hair conditioner is my personal go-to in emergencies. I discovered this hack while travelling. As Harb points out, conditioner is 'already designed to soften hair, so it offers decent lubrication.' It's slick enough to let the razor glide without too much resistance.
Coconut Oil
Coconut oil has saved my skin more than once when I've been caught short. Clark is a fan, describing it as 'a great natural option that provides a slick surface while also moisturising the skin.'
Olive Oil
Olive oil might seem like a leftfield choice, but this kitchen staple can provide the lubrication needed for a passable shave in an absolute pinch.
Aloe Vera Gel
Aloe vera gel has come to my rescue during summer getaways when I've packed sunscreen but forgotten shaving cream. Harb recommends it for its 'soothing and hydrating properties,' making it particularly good for sensitive skin.
Warm Water and Hot Towel
Even warm water and a hot towel can suffice in the most desperate situations. As Clark explains, properly hydrating the skin and beard hair before shaving makes a significant difference, even without additional products.
But bear in mind that while warm water can soften beard hair, using water alone provides minimal lubrication and significantly increases your risk of razor burn and skin irritation. For a safer experience, combine warm water with at least some form of lubricant like conditioner or natural oil, and always use light, careful strokes.
How To Shave Without Shaving Cream
Both experts stress that proper preparation and technique become crucial when using alternative products. Consider taking the following steps:
- Proper preparation: 'Hydrate the skin first — shaving after a warm shower or using a hot towel helps soften the hair and opens the pores, making for an easier glide,' advises Clark.
- Apply your alternative: Whichever substitute you're using, apply it generously to create as much of a barrier as possible.
- Use the correct technique: 'Shorter, lighter strokes are best, and you'll want to rinse the blade frequently to keep it from clogging, especially if you're using something thicker like conditioner or oil,' suggests Harb. Clark adds: 'Use light pressure — since alternative products may not cushion the razor as well as shaving cream, using a light touch helps prevent irritation.'
- Direction matters: 'Shave with the grain first — this reduces the risk of razor burn, especially when lubrication is limited,' says Clark. Going against the grain increases your risk of irritation when using substitutes.
- Keep it clean: 'Rinse the blade often — oils and conditioners can clog up razors faster than shaving cream, so keeping the blade clean ensures a smoother shave,' Clark emphasises.
Who Should Avoid Shaving Without Proper Products?
Both experts identify specific groups who should stick to proper shaving products:
'Men with sensitive or dry skin should avoid shaving without proper products, as they're more prone to irritation, razor burn and post-shave redness,’ warns Clark.
I recommend the NIVEA MEN Sensitive Pro Ultra Calming Liquid Shaving Cream or Kiehl’s Ultimate Brushless Shave Cream for those with sensitive skin looking for a close shave.
Clark further notes: ‘Those with thicker or coarser beards may also struggle, as their hair requires more softening before shaving to prevent tugging and discomfort.'
Post-Shave Care
Aftercare becomes even more crucial if you’re not using traditional shaving methods. Consider incorporating the following practices:
- Apply a cool compress to reduce redness and close pores.
- Use a gentle, fragrance-free moisturiser to restore hydration.
- Avoid harsh, alcohol-based aftershaves that can further dry the skin.
- Consider using products with salicylic acid a day or two after shaving if you're prone to ingrown hairs.
Verdict
It's good to know that alternatives exist for those emergency situations. With proper preparation, technique and diligent aftercare, you can achieve a decent shave using substitute items.
The next time you find yourself staring down an empty tube of shaving cream, remember: all is not lost. Just be prepared to put in a little extra care and attention to avoid turning a grooming emergency into a skin catastrophe.
More Grooming Advice
- The 7 Best Electric Shavers for Men, Tried and Tested
- The 8 Best Beard Trimmers for Men: Expert-Tested for Precision and Performance
- Shaving Gel, Foam or Cream: Which Is Better?
- Aftershave vs. Cologne vs. Eau De Toilette: What's the Difference?
